I believe, many non-Muslims are eager to hear an answer to such questions from the mouth of Islamic resources. Particularly under the big wave of Islamophobia in the Western world, and the number of violent incidents made allegedly in the name of Islam. So, it's important to talk about the basis of Islamic perspective about non-Muslims. Hatred or Love? Marginalizing or Merging? Fighting or Cooperation? Separation or Coexistence?
The best way to understand Islamic perspective about the relation between Muslims and non-Muslims is to follow what Prophet Muhammad said and practiced. This way we can focus on the theoretical principles set for Muslims to treat non-Muslims, and in the same way see a practical application of these principles.
It's important at first to clarify that everything that Prophet Muhammad say or do, is considered to be a legislation for all Muslims. If Qur'an is the first source of Shari'a (Islamic legislation), then sayings and deeds of the Prophet are the second source. Qur'an says; "Ye have indeed in the Messenger of Allah a beautiful pattern (of conduct) for any one whose hope is in Allah and the Final Day, and who engages much in the Praise of Allah." 33th chapter: 21th verse. Subsequently, when the Prophet do something or say anything, all Muslims are required to do the same as he did and apply what he said. All Muslims consider Prophet Muhammad as the best example for them..
When the message of Islam started to spread in its early beginning, the people of Mecca started to murder new Muslims, torture them, besiege and boycott them, and expropriate their properties. This sufferance lasted for 13 years. The atmosphere in Mecca has not become suitable for Muslims to live, so they had to immigrate to another place away from the reach of Meccans. The choice was Medina, 450 KM away from Mecca. Medina was a place where Jews settled long time before. The first thing Prophet Muhammad did after he migrated to Medina was to sign a treaty, including all tribes of Medina beside Jewish tribes. The main clauses of that treaty were;
*The Jews will profess their religion, and the Muslims theirs.
*If attacked by a third party, each shall come to the assistance of the other.
*Neither shall commit sins to the prejudice of the other.
*The wronged party shall be aided.
*Each shall contribute to defending Madinah, in case of a foreign attack, in its respective area.
*This treaty shall not hinder either party from seeking lawful revenge.
There are major values seen in these clauses such as; Freedom of religion, Merging Jews in community instead of marginalizing them, Setting the basics of justice and equity, Supporting the right regardless of faith. Prophet Muhammad practiced these values 14 centuries ago!
In Qur'an, 60th Chapter, 7th & 8th verse say;"It may be that Allah will grant love (and friendship) between you and those whom ye (now) hold as enemies. For Allah has power (over all things); And Allah is Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful. * Allah forbids you not, with regard to those who fight you not for (your) Faith nor drive you out of your homes, from dealing kindly and justly with them: for Allah loveth those who are just." In addition, Prophet Muhammad -God bless him- said about Dhimmis (non-Muslims living under Islamic protection); "He who hurts a Dhimmi hurts me, and he who hurts me annoys Allah." Reported by Al-Tabarani. The two verses and the Hadith (Saying of the Prophet) show very clearly the main frame of how a Muslim should treat non-Muslims.
If we started by the Hadith we can realize that it's a big sin and a forbidden thing to hurt non-Muslims. What is a "hurt"? This include everything that would annoy any human; mistreat, transgression and oppression. We aren't talking here about bombing civilian places and random shooting. If Prophet Muhammad considered hurting, just the hurt at any level, as hurting for himself and subsequently to God (Which devout Muslim would dare to do something that hurt the Prophet and annoy Allah?), then, higher levels of hurt like attacking and killing them is an unforgivable crime.
The two verses maintain the peace that must be achieved between Muslims and non-Muslims who don't aim at fighting and driving Muslims out of their homes. Peace for peace, that's it. These verses include all non-Muslims; Christians, Jews, and even the infidels. "Kindly and Justly", a very clear order. Smiling, Giving a present, Exchanging friendly visits, Sharing the food, Volunteering in social projects, Selling & Buying, Medical treatment, Sharing in social occasions, Helping the needy, Giving the poor, .. there is so much other to say, it's simply; "Dealing Kindly and Justly"!
Another short incident that Prophet Muhammad did, but, I believe, it has much to tell Muslims about treating non-Muslims. One day a funeral procession passed by and the Prophet (PBUH) stoop up. The people objected. "But it is the funeral of a Jews." and he responded, "Is he not a human being?"
I asked myself "What is the message out of that?", "What did Prophet Muhammad want to tell his companions?". I think the message is clear. Prophet Muhammad, the Prophet of Islam is telling Muslims that when we treat non-Muslims kindly, it's not about cheating them, but it's all about respecting them .. just because they are human beings. It's about respecting their souls and their dignity, whatever they believe in.
In another occasion, a delegation of Christian Yemenis arrived to Medina to meet Prophet Muhammad. The Prophet welcomed them in the mosque of Medina. When the time of their prayer came, they prayed at the mosque, and the Prophet allowed them! Prophet Muhammad is not just telling Muslims that we should give non-Muslims the freedom of practicing their faith, but in addition, we might share them our worshiping places, our mosques, to practice their worshiping. So open-minded, so civilized!
When the Prophet was migrating from Mecca to Medina secretly, the people of Mecca was chasing him to assassinate him, they even sent 10 strong young men with sharp swords to his house to kill him, but God saved him (PBUH). The situation was so risky, any mistake would lead to the death of the Prophet, the messenger of God, and the receiver of the revelation. When the Prophet needed a guide to show him the way to Medina through the desert without being seen by the Meccans, he choose Abdullah Ibn Urayket, one of the Meccans, a good guide, and .. a non-Muslim!
Thinking of it, the Prophet of Islam trusted a non-Muslim in that critical situation. He would easily reveal the secret to the Meccans, and win the 100 camels prize that Meccans made for anyone who tell them about the place of the Prophet. But the Prophet didn't looked at him that way, instead he looked at how good he was as a guide who knows the secret roads to Medina and how honest and trusted he was so not to reveal his secret. The Prophet trusted him i.e. trusted a non-Muslim! This tell all Muslims very clearly that working with a non-Muslim, is no thing bad.
One of the most important Hadith (Sayings of the Prophet) about the security of the non-Muslims' lives is the following. The Prophet of Islam said; "Whoever kills a person whom we have a treaty will not even come close enough to Paradise to smell its scent, and its scent can be found at a distance of forty years travel." Reported by Bukhari
No thing would be more clear. All those who bomb themselves in civil places thinking that they are dying as "martyrs" who will go to paradise, all those who kill randomly by the name of Islam thinking that they are practicing the noble Jihad, and all those who terrorize the safe non-Muslims, all of them must hear that saying of the Prophet. The Prophet is telling them that they will not even approach to paradise after their death.
An application of that Hadith was made in the life of the Prophet. It has been recorded in more than one source that one of the Muslims killed a man from the People of the Covenant, and the case was brought before the Prophet Muhammad (Peace Be Upon Him), who said; "I am the one most obliged to fulfill his covenant" and ordered the murderer to be executed. A Muslim was executed because he killed one non-Muslim! That's Shari'a!
These were few examples of how Prophet Muhammad, the Prophet of Islam, treated non-Muslims. In fact, that's what are we, Muslims, required to be with non-Muslims, those who live with us in the same place, and share us the same planet. We're required to love them not to hate them, to make peace with them not to terrorize them, to coexist with them not to kill them. That's what my religion, Islam, tell me to do.
Thanks Mohamed,
ReplyDeleteVery interesting post. I knew very little of this history. The part about the relationship between the Jews and Muslims in Medina was especially enlightening.
Rory
Thanks for this entry. As a Christian, the gospel tells me many stories of how Jesus taught by example. I think it's hard for a lot of people to believe what is right or even that there is a God.
ReplyDeleteAt the same time, science has discovered there is in every person a desire to seek out God. That is true, to seek. There is a verse in the Bible, seek ye first the kingdom of heaven and all shall be added to you. This is to say, seek the kingdom wherein there is God and He will be there.
It is a pretty complex statement, considering God is in every single thing. I am not perfect by any expression, but it is my duty to seek out God in everything, plant, mineral or animal.
At such times as America is now facing, Christians should be seeking...still. It's easy and natural to blame, hurt and destroy. But, as one is destroying, I, in my own way must seek.
I think this is a fundamental precept of my faith.
Moonlitewine wrote,
ReplyDeleteAt such times as America is now facing, Christians should be seeking...still. It's easy and natural to blame, hurt and destroy.
This is true for Ireland too. The country is sinking into despair. We must seek the light, love and positive solutions.
Rory
Moonlite,
ReplyDeleteYou mentioned a verse form the Bible; Seek ye first the kingdom of heaven and all shall be added to you.
I believe we have a similar verse in the Qur'an;
"Behold! in the creation of the heavens and the earth, and the alternation of night and day,- there are indeed Signs for men of understanding,-
* Men who celebrate the praises of Allah, standing, sitting, and lying down on their sides, and contemplate the (wonders of) creation in the heavens and the earth, (With the thought): "Our Lord! not for naught Hast Thou created (all) this! Glory to Thee! Give us salvation from the penalty of the Fire. "
3: 190, 191
They find God through contemplation and searching.
One thing I remember from childhood is getting into trouble for two things: not behaving as a young girl ought, and asking too many questions.
ReplyDeleteIt's funny. In the age of instant information, children have fewer chances to listen in on adult conversation or ask those questions, like, "Why can't we see the wind?"
I remember one time, when the twins were preschoolers, and they asked me all sorts of questions about pregnancy, birth, etc. One of the twins asked me how come the baby doesn't fall out from its birth opening.
I explained, that there is a special connection between the mother and the child. I told the children that if they look at their belly button, they could see the remains of that connection. I went on to tell them about a rope between the mother and child, which is inside the body of the mother and the outside of the baby, and that it is there to help the baby grow and stay safe.
The woman next to me, a nurse, was very upset about me misrepresenting science in such a way. Really. Were the twins wanting to know every known fact about reproduction of humans? No. I chose that opportunity to let my young children know how natural and well constructed reproduction is. I told them that they were really safe from the beginning, hoping to instill the same at that moment.
Last, my answer gave them imagination to contemplate. The twins believed me then. Now? Now the twins are naughty teens. I find I get deeper response if I use the same theory of being connected to me than any other words I could use.
This may seem off-subject. But it's a story about seeking, really.
Moonlite,
ReplyDeleteHowever I'm not a father, (and of course not a mother ;)) I think that when a child asks me about something, I'll simplify the information for him, even if I'll give it to him in a sort of story. I don't have to give it to him in a scientific way, but in the way that will make him understand it.
Thanks for the nice story.
By the way, I liked your expression; "Age of Instant information". Yes, it's truly the age of instant, ready and easy information. Ask and you'll get the information at once, no need for any research!
"Ask and you'll get the MISinformation at once . . . ."
ReplyDeleteOf course Mohamed doesn't want you to do any research, Moonlite. He wants you to swallow whole his half-truths and outright, bald-faced lies.
I can understand Rory falling for that nonsense -- he'd rather count words than pay attention to what they mean -- but you? And you're a Christian?
Do you care that Muhammad called Christ a "blasphemer"? That he "sacralized" violating all Ten Commandments and the Golden Rule?
That Muhammad practiced genocide, pedophilia, rape, mutilation, torture, slavery, theft, extortion, polygamy, and religious and gender apartheid, claimed that "allah made me do it," and commanded others to do the same?
Did you even notice that Mohamed's quote commands to refrain from killing "those with whom we have a treaty"?
Of course Muhammad didn't want everyone dead; he needed non-Muslims from whom to extract tribute, slave labor, and sexual gratification.
"My enemy's enemy is my friend," may be true in many cases, but like Mohamed's post, there's more to it when it comes to Islam.
Leftists may welcome a rival to Christianity now, but what you don't realize is that once Christianity is marginalized or dead in the West, you're next.
And Islam is no gentle master. Just ask all those around the world today and from the past 1400 years who've endured Muslims' obedience to this:
"the Messenger of Allah . . . would say: 'Fight in the name of Allah and in the way of Allah. Fight against those who disbelieve in Allah. Make a holy war. . . . When you meet your enemies who are polytheists, invite them to three courses of action. . . . Invite them to (accept) Islam; if they respond to you, accept it from them and desist from fighting against them. . . . If they refuse to accept Islam, demand from them the Jizya. If they agree to pay, accept it from them and hold off your hands. If they refuse to pay the tax, seek Allah's help and fight them . . .'" (Muslim Book 19, Number 4294).
And this:
ReplyDelete"fight and slay the Pagans wherever ye find them, and seize them, beleaguer them, and lie in wait for them in every stratagem (of war) . . . " (Qur’an 9:5).
"Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued" (Qur'an 9:29).
"The punishment of those who wage war against Allah and His Messenger, and strive with might and main for mischief through the land is: execution, or crucifixion, or the cutting off of hands and feet from opposite sides, or exile from the land: that is their disgrace in this world, and a heavy punishment is theirs in the Hereafter . . . " (Qur'an 5:33). [Ibn Kathir says of this verse: "'Wage war' mentioned here means, oppose and contradict, and it includes disbelief, blocking roads and spreading fear in the fairways. Mischief in the land refers to various types of evil." So, Muhammad requires execution, crucifixion, or cutting off hands and feet from opposite sides for "disbelief."]
"Allah's Apostle said: 'I have been ordered (by Allah) to fight against the people until they testify that none has the right to be worshipped but Allah and that Muhammad is Allah's Apostle . . . '" (Bukhari Volume 1, Book 2, Number 24).
"It is not for any prophet to have captives until he hath made slaughter in the land. Ye desire the lure of this world and Allah desireth (for you) the Hereafter, and Allah is Mighty, Wise" (Qur'an 8:67).
"Allah’s Apostle said, 'I have been made victorious with terror'" (Bukhari Volume 4, Book 52, Number 220).
http://amillennialist.blogspot.com/2004/07/allah-and-his-false-prophet-command.html
Amillennialist
So, Mohamed,
ReplyDeleteYou never answered my question (though you deleted it from your site): What is it about Muhammad that appeals to you, the genocide, the mutilation and torture, or the pedophilia?
Are you still defending mid-fifties-Muhammad's raping little, nine-year-old, prepubescent 'Aisha by claiming, "She liked it!"?
Moonlite, do you care at all that you're allying with someone who defends such vile filth? Who facilitates on religious grounds pedophilia, rape, (actual) torture, slavery, and genocide?
Do you care that Rory is unable to denounce such utter evil?
Will you?
Amilleniest,
ReplyDeleteNo sign of Mahomed or Moonlitewine the last few days, they may respond to your comments in time, as for me, The Loop Garroo Kid got it right when he described me as a secular humanist.
I am also a skeptical catholic, but a catholic none the less. I believe in tolerance for all belief systems.
But here are my list of priorities in life, just to nip this in the bud:
1. Spirituality (practicing love and tolerance)
2. Socialism
3. Work
4. Play
5. Religion
Based on these priorities, and the fact that I am a busy man, I have little time for long winded religious debates. I speak only for myself, not my fellow contributors to this blog. So stick around if you will, but if you insult me enough I might get angry, and I am like the Incredable Hulk, you won't like me when I'm angry.
Rory
I knew Bill Bixby. You're no Bill Bixby.
ReplyDeleteAnd the fact is, not only did you refuse to denounce those atrocities, but now you give Mohamed Fadly -- whose defense of Muhammad's pedophilia is, "But she liked it!" -- a platform here and whatever legitimacy that confers.
You can't justify uncritically endorsing evil by claiming that you "have little time for long winded religious debates." You have a responsibility to know the subject matter you're promoting.
Now's as good a time as any to do the right thing. Do you denounce Muhammad's "sacralizing" genocide, pedophilia, rape, mutilation, torture, slavery, theft, extortion, polygamy, religious and gender apartheid, and blasphemy, his claiming that "Allah made me do it," and his commanding others to do the same, or not?
Do I denounce,? Short answer, No.
ReplyDeleteThere are one billion Muslim worldwide and the vast, overwhelming majority do not practice most of the nasty things you mention.
Gender apartheid, which I do denounce being the exception. But even this was practiced in most Christian countries until very recently.
As for allowing Mahomed a platform, I feel he is a good representative of the 1,000,000 mostly moderate Muslims worldwide. I have been looking for a conservative contributor to balance out the blog, but so far have been unable to find one with any sense of reality. Most blame president Obama for the financial crisis, the weather, the poor quality of prime time TV.
Rory
What Did Muhammad Tell Us To Do?
ReplyDeleteA. Well, he told us to do lots of cruel stuff, including "Pay the Jizya Tax, with willing submission, and feel...subdued!"
Qur'an 9:29
______________________________________________
Muslims out-number Jews 100 to one; in scientific achievements and creative literature...you need only to reverse the numbers! Why is that?
ReplyDeleteEducation of their men...and their women.
Of course, the authors - Nonie Darwich and Wafa Sultan are the noted exceptions - These two wisely chose Freedom from Oppression!
reb
____________________________________________
What happened to Moshe Dayan's {Post}? ?
ReplyDeleteLots of good comments there. - reb
_ _ _
Reb,
ReplyDelete'The Sayings of Moshe Dayan' post is stll in the December Archive, with all comments.
Rory
Rory is true to his word, allowing Amillenialist
ReplyDeleteand SnakeHunter to expound logical viewpoints.
Rory's extolling the virtues of Socialism, while acknowledging the 200 yrs of 'Christian Crusade'.. and ignoring the 1400 years of Muslim Crusades in a dozen nations, does not speak well of Rory's ability to fairly analyse and judge the obvious. The Muslim on-Muslim atrocities in Palestine, Iraq & Afganistan continue, and the innocent population suffers; nothing changes.. blame the Jews; blame the Great Satan, America.
So-called "Moderate Muslims" that adhere to the teachings of The Muslim Brotherhood that have skillfully infiltrated Europe & the USA are well known and tracked by succeeding administrations, like their Council American-Islamic Relations C.A.I.R. groups, funded by Saudi Arabia and spreading across the U.S. like a deadly cancer.
The weakness of the Obama advisors, including many "old guard" House & Senate Democrats are in for a rude awakening come November 2nd, 2010...
Alert citizens have come to realize the peril of these "moderate infil.traitors", and the smug attitude of petty politicians on the Left! - reb
_____________________________________________